Characteristics of a Worthy Dish

The dish must reflect a longstanding culinary tradition tied to a specific region or community, often passed down through generations. For example, a Quebecois tourtière (meat pie) with recipes dating to the 17th-century French settlers would qualify.

It should use traditional ingredients and techniques, with minimal modern adaptations, showcasing heritage methods. A Sicilian arancini, hand-rolled with Arborio rice and saffron as prepared since the 10th-century Arab influence, fits this.

Authenticity and Historical Integrity

The dish must demonstrate deep roots and a strong connection to a specific ancient or historical period and culture.

Adherence to Original Methods: Use of cooking techniques, tools, and processes that faithfully replicate those used historically (e.g., open fire cooking, fermentation, use of clay pots).

Original Ingredient Sourcing: Utilization of ingredients that were genuinely available and commonly used during the period. This often means featuring heirloom grains, heritage livestock breeds, wild-foraged foods, or specific ancient spices and fats.

.

Culinary Skill and Execution

The preparation must showcase a high level of expertise in executing challenging historical recipes.

Balance of Flavors: Achieve a flavor profile that, while potentially unfamiliar to modern palates, is considered harmonious and authentic to the historical context.

Technique Mastery: Flawless execution of specific ancient preservation methods (e.g., salting, curing, oil preservation) or complex historical cooking steps.